Why New York's New Workplace Transparency Law Is Sparking Debate Among Global HR Teams
By Reetika Gupta, Founder, Aristo Legal
Published Nov 18, 2026·
Updated Nov 18, 2026
New York now requires employers to hand over personnel files within five (05) business days and disclose negative entries within ten (10). For Indian GCCs and multinationals, it's a preview of where global HR documentation standards are headed and a reminder of how thin India's own protections still are.
Key takeaways:
New York's Section 210-b (effective Nov 8, 2026) requires every employer, public, private, any size, to provide personnel records within five (05) business days and to notify employees within ten (10) calendar days of any negative entry, with a right of rebuttal.
India has no private-sector equivalent. The closest Indian precedent, the Supreme Court's Dev Dutt v. Union of India (2008) 8 SCC 725, binds only government employers.
The DPDP Act, 2023 gives employees a right to a data summary, but broad "employment-related purposes" exemptions limit its reach.
2026 rulings, the Bombay HC on RTI-exempt service records, and the Supreme Court's PIL on background-verification firms, show Indian courts are actively shaping this space, case by case, in the absence of a statute.
For decades, the corporate HR file has been treated like a locked vault. Employees rarely got to see what went inside until a promotion was denied, a bonus was cut, or a termination notice landed on their desk.
On November 8, 2026, New York State flipped that script. Under New York Labor Law Section 210-b, every public and private employer in New York, regardless of company size, must now give current and former employees a free copy of their personnel records within five (05) business days of a written request. Even more notably, employers must notify workers within ten (10) calendar days whenever negative information is added to their file that could hurt their prospects for promotion, pay, or continued employment, and allow the employee to attach a written rebuttal.
While this law applies directly to New York workplaces and remote workers reporting into New York, it has triggered an intense debate across global HR teams including Global Capability Centres (GCCs) and multinational firms operating in India.
Why Global HR Teams Are Divided
The rollout of Section 210-b has exposed a sharp divide between worker advocates and corporate compliance leaders:
Worker Advocates Push for 10-Day Alerts to Prevent Hidden Bias
Employee-rights groups argue that secret files enable workplace bias, retaliation, and arbitrary exits. Knowing within 10 days that a negative remark has been logged gives workers a fair chance to correct misunderstandings or add context before appraisal cycles close.
HR Leaders Warn 5-Day Deadlines Will Strain Teams and Deter Candid Feedback
Many HR leaders warn that a five-business-day turnaround is punishing for lean teams, especially since "personnel records" under the law broadly cover applications, pay histories, performance reviews, and disciplinary notes including data held by third-party payroll and HR vendors. Others fear managers will stop writing candid performance feedback altogether to avoid triggering mandatory 10-day notices and formal employee rebuttals.
This has led to an operational dilemma: multinational companies with teams split between New York, Bengaluru, Hyderabad, and London must choose between running a two-tier HR system, where US colleagues enjoy statutory file access while offshore teammates do not or adopting New York's strict documentation standards globally.
The Global Landscape: How Other Regions Handle Employee Files
New York is not acting in a vacuum, though its 10-day negative-notice rule is unusually strict:
European Union & UK (GDPR): Under the General Data Protection Regulation, employees across the EU and UK have long held the right to file a Data Subject Access Request (DSAR) to obtain copies of their personal HR data, typically within one month.
Other US States: States like California, Illinois, and Massachusetts already grant employees statutory rights to inspect or copy their personnel files, with Massachusetts also requiring employers to notify workers within 10 days of placing negative information in their records.
Singapore & Australia: Data protection laws (such as Singapore’s PDPA and Australia’s Privacy Act) give employees general rights to access personal information held about them, though specific exemptions often apply to confidential management planning or ongoing internal investigations.
Where India Stands: Laws and Recent Court Rulings
Unlike New York, India has no central or state labour statute, including the four Labour Codes or state Shops and Establishments Acts, that grants private-sector employees the right to inspect their full internal HR file or receive alerts for negative remarks. Employees are only entitled to specific adverse documents (such as a show-cause notice, charge sheet, or inquiry report) under principles of natural justice and applicable standing orders once formal disciplinary proceedings begin. Even the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, which exempts routine employment-related processing, only allows individuals to request a summary of their personal data, not internal managerial evaluations or confidential HR notes.
However, Indian courts have grappled with strikingly similar questions for nearly two decades just within the narrower lane of public-sector service law and recent 2026 rulings show employee records are becoming a major legal battleground across three fronts.
1. The "right to know" about adverse remarks
Long before New York legislated a 10-day notice rule, the Supreme Court had already built a near-identical doctrine for government employees. In Dev Dutt v. Union of India (2008) 8 SCC 725, the Court held that every entry in a government servant's Annual Confidential Report, whether "outstanding," "good," "average," or adverse, must be communicated to the employee within a reasonable time, so they can make a representation against it before it affects their career.
A Constitution Bench reaffirmed this in Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India (2013) 9 SCC 573, holding that silently filing adverse entries without disclosure violates natural justice and Article 14. The principle was applied again in Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar v. Union of India (2009) 16 SCC 146, where a promotion denial was struck down because the adverse entry behind it had never been communicated.
The catch: this entire line of cases binds government and public-sector employers only. India has never extended an equivalent statutory or judicial mandate to private companies — which is exactly the gap Section 210-b fills in New York and that Indian private-sector HR currently lacks.
2. Access to one's own file held by an institution
A second line of cases deals with whether a person can demand their own records from an organisation that holds them. In CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011) 8 SCC 497, the Supreme Court allowed students to access their own evaluated answer scripts under the RTI Act, reasoning that confidentiality exemptions exist to protect other people's information, not to block a person from their own data the conceptual ancestor of "give employees a copy of their own file."
The flip side came in Girish Ramchandra Deshpande v. CIC (2013) 1 SCC 212, where the Court held that a third party's RTI request for someone else's service records — ACRs, penalties, assets — counts as exempt "personal information" under Section 8(1)(j) unless larger public interest is shown. The Bombay High Court built on this in April 2026, reinforcing that a public servant's service records qualify as protected personal information exempt from third-party RTI disclosure absent a demonstrated public interest.
3. Data privacy, background checks, and the DPDP Act
Indian employees are gaining stronger rights over how their data is shared externally.
Under Section 7(i) of the DPDP Act 2023, employers (as Data Fiduciaries) may process employee personal data for "employment purposes" or for protecting the employer from loss or liability under legitimate use grounds without requiring explicit consent. However, employees maintain statutory rights as Data Principals under Sections 11 and 12 to obtain a summary of personal data being processed and the identities of third-party Data Processors. Crucially, the right to a data summary under the DPDP Act does NOT grant private-sector employees an automatic right to access, inspect, or copy internal managerial evaluations, subjective performance appraisals, peer reviews, stack-ranking calibration notes, or promotion deliberations. The DPDP Act is a general data privacy framework regulating personal data processing not a labor transparency statute granting access to internal management opinions.
The constitutional foundation underneath all of this is Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India (2017) 10 SCC 1, the nine-judge bench that recognised privacy as a fundamental right under Article 21 — the ruling the DPDP Act, and every subsequent employee-data case, ultimately traces back to.
That foundation is now being tested against unauthorised commercial use of employee data. In August 2026 (Piyush Chhabra v. Union of India), the Supreme Court directed the Union government to examine allegations that private background-verification firms were pulling workers' EPFO, UAN, PAN, and tax records without OTPs or visible consent.
Taken together, Dev Dutt v. Union of India (2008) 8 SCC 725 through Puttaswamy show that Indian courts have already endorsed the values underlying Section 210-b — notice before harm, access to one's own data, protection from unauthorised third-party access — but have never stitched them into a single private-sector statute the way New York just did.
The regulatory gap, stated plainly: Dev Dutt v. Union of India (2008) 8 SCC 725 and Sukhdev Singh bind government and PSU employers under service law. There is no equivalent compelling a private company — an IT major, a startup, a GCC — to disclose adverse entries to an employee within a fixed window. That is the open space Section 210-b points at, and Indian private-sector HR policy currently has nothing filling it.
What This Means for Indian HR Leaders and Professionals
For Indian companies especially IT firms, startups, and GCCs working closely with US stakeholders New York's Section 210-b is a clear warning sign. Global employment standards are moving toward audit-ready, transparent documentation.
HR teams in India may not face a five-day statutory deadline today, but between tightening data privacy enforcement, stricter EPFO scrutiny, growing judicial sympathy for an employee's right to know what's in their own file, and rising expectations from a globally connected workforce, the era of informal, unverified, or secret HR files is rapidly coming to an end.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does India have a law like New York's personnel file access law (Section 210-b)?
No. India has no standalone private-sector statute requiring employers to hand over personnel files on request or to flag negative entries within a fixed window. The closest Indian precedent is Dev Dutt v. Union of India (2008) 8 SCC 725 where Supreme Court cases requiring disclosure of adverse remarks — applies only to government and public-sector employees, not private companies.
Can Indian employees ask to see their own HR or service file?
Government employees have a judicially recognised right to be informed of adverse entries in their service record, established in Dev Dutt v. Union of India (2008) and reaffirmed in Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India (2013). Private-sector employees have no equivalent statutory right in India today; access depends on company policy and, to a limited extent, the DPDP Act's data-summary provision.
What does the DPDP Act, 2023 say about an employee's right to their data?
The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 gives employees, as Data Principals, the right to request a summary of personal data an employer processes about them. However, the Act carries broad exemptions for employment-related purposes, which limits how far this right reaches in practice.
Are adverse remarks in an employee's file legally required to be disclosed in India?
Only for government servants. The Supreme Court held in Dev Dutt v. Union of India (2008) 8 SCC 725 that every entry in a government employee's Annual Confidential Report — good, average, or adverse — must be communicated within a reasonable time so the employee can respond. This was reaffirmed by a Constitution Bench in Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India (2013) 9 SCC 573. No equivalent rule binds private employers.
Can a background-verification firm access an employee's EPFO, UAN, or PAN records without consent?
This is under active scrutiny. In Piyush Chhabra v. Union of India (August 2026), the Supreme Court directed the Union government to examine allegations that private background-verification firms were accessing EPFO, UAN, PAN, and tax records without OTP-based or visible consent.
Is a government employee's service record accessible under the RTI Act?
Generally no, if requested by a third party. The Supreme Court in Girish Ramchandra Deshpande v. CIC (2013) 1 SCC 212 held that service records are exempt personal information under RTI Section 8(1)(j) unless larger public interest is shown. The Bombay High Court reinforced this in April 2026, holding that a public servant's service records remain protected absent a demonstrated public interest.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Case citations are given in standard reporter format for independent verification against official sources (e.g., Supreme Court of India, SCC Online, Indian Kanoon); readers should confirm current status before relying on them.




Comments